- All Topics
Europe and AfricaExternal RelationsFood and AgricultureGame ParksGovernanceHealthHuman RightsICTInfrastructureInnovationInternational OrganisationsInvestmentLabourLand and Rural IssuesLatin America and AfricaLegal AffairsMalariaManufacturingMediaMiddle East and AfricaMigrationMiningMusicMusic ReviewsNCDsNGONutrition
- All Topics
When South African academics want to set up a new degree module, they’re entering into a process that can take years to germinate. These modules must be approved through an incredibly cumbersome process – departmental, school, faculty, various university quality control committees, an institution’s senate, the South African Qualification Authority. Only then can they be registered by the National Qualification Framework.
This is just one example of the bureaucratic chores that now occupy academics’ days. It’s a reality that prompted me to edit a new book called Making Sense of Research (Van Schaik, Pretoria, 2018). It’s written by supervisors, deans, research coordinators and lecturers who offer suggestions about how students and academics can negotiate the reams of red tape that typify modern universities.
Bureaucracy is necessary to manage large institutions. But it can also be alienating. It alienates the researcher from their field or discipline. It alienates those who are researched from those who conduct the research. And ultimately, it alienates both researchers and the researched from the academy.
Take the example of student protests held under the banner of “fees must fall” between 2015 and 2017. Events unfolded on an hourly basis at breakneck speed. These deserved careful study and scrutiny by trained academics who knew what questions to ask and what information could be gleaned. But procedural knots meant it was impossible to secure ethical clearance, for instance, and this hampered knowledge production.
That in turn hampered the benefits for the public, who could have learned from research conducted on the ground during these important protests. And then researchers are dismissed as being distanced from the real world – irrelevant and out of touch with breaking events. The problem, of course, is that real world events don’t conform with research committee schedules.
Dodging red tape
This trend towards bureaucratised research and teaching, particularly in the humanities, has come about because outputs must be measured, managed, and made to justify bottom lines to qualify for state subsidies. Everything from students – too many – to resources – too few – must be managed, administered and audited.
Bureaucracy, as anyone who has encountered it knows, makes it increasingly difficult to get any work done. For academics this means that field work is placed on the back burner. Just registering a topic for field work can take many months and involve multiple committees and numerous university divisions. These time-consuming and increasingly cumbersome procedures – though often necessary – delay the start of work, students’ progress through a degree and publications linked to the planned field work.
This process alienates academics from the “meat” of their work, the active research that produces nuanced results. Many students and their supervisors are responding defensively. They simply conduct desk-top research that relies on texts already published by other scholars.
This is the quickest, cheapest route. It helps both academics and the students they supervise to circumvent red tape. But it’s a route that excludes subject communities or research participants who used to be the focus of interactive academic work. These groups are left in the background and reduced to mere texts in contemporary research projects.
So the instrumentalisation of research practices alienates those who have traditionally cooperated with researchers and who expect tangible benefits from such partnerships.
The third alienation is of researchers and the researched from the academy. What works for the university as an institution does not necessarily work for the lecturers or students. Students do research because this is a curriculum requirement. But they must also become aware of why they are doing research, who it will benefit (or disadvantage) and what the implications might be
There is a fourth alienation, too, exemplified by the many hoops academics must jump through to register and begin teaching a new module or the requirements for designing field work. Knowledge has a rapidly decreasing half-life. It is being revised continuously. Too much bureaucracy alienates academics and students from breaking developments that impact their own disciplines.
Over-regulation means academics are often teaching approved but outdated knowledge rather than updating it daily.
The good news is that this alienation can be turned around. In Making Sense of Research, contributors offer advice for making sense of academic rituals. It’s not a dry book about “how to” research as much as it is about “why” do research and how to negotiate the institutional swamps in conducting it.
Ordinary academics can kick back against the system in a useful way, despite the cautioning effects of managerialism. There are creative ways to deal with bureaucracy; the best is to take students off campus and into the fields of the real world.
Books and articles about the real world must be complemented with direct exposure to those worlds. Bureaucrats must recognise that experiential learning is the best kind. Sitting in classrooms and being referred solely to books that other people wrote is only half the story. The full story involves getting one’s hands dirty in the field, too. That may be costly; it may transgress timetable schedules and stress capacity – but it must be done to tackle the growing problem of academic alienation from life.
Zimbabwean president Emmerson Mnangagwa and South African comedian Trevor Noah have been featured on TIME magazine’s 100… Read more »
Copyright © 2018 The Conversation. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica publishes around 800 reports a day from more than 140 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.
- South Africa: Trevor Noah, Mnangagwa Named in TIME 100 Most Influential List
- South Africa: Former President Zuma a New Father at 76
- South Africa: Metrorail Delays Hit Cape Town Commuters, As Bus Strike Continues
- South Africa: Mahikeng Protests – Ramaphosa to ‘Lend a Hand’
- South Africa: Western Cape ANC to March in Solidarity With Palestine
- South Africa: Check Out South Africa’s Music Award Nominees
- South Africa: Bus Strike Enters Third Day
- South Africa: DA to Seek Review of Former Spy Boss Fraser’s Appointment At Correctional Services
- South Africa: Jean-Luc Du Plessis, Malherbe Return for WP
- South Africa: Missing Persons Sought By Pietermaritzburg Police
- South Africa: Judgment Reserved in Muslim Marriages Case
- South Africa: Drug Clean-Up Operations Continue in Uitenhage Cluster
- South Africa: Assisting Prisoners to Escape – Two Johannesburg Correctional Service Members Appear in Court
- South Africa: A 23-Year-Old Hijacking Suspect Arrested
- South Africa: Police Arrested One of Their Own On a Charge of Murder
- South Africa: Study Urges Action to Save Philippi’s Farms
- Trevor Noah, Mnangagwa Named Among World’s Most Influential
- Musicians Battle It Out for South Africa’s Top Awards
- South African President Cuts Short UK Trip to Put Out Home Fires
- Protesters Held After ‘Hide and Seek’ With South African Police
- Culpable Homicide Charge Comes Back to Haunt Zuma’s Son
- Political Party Looking for ‘Shortcut’ to Remove Cape Town Mayor?
- 300 Cleopatra Era Artifacts Displayed for First Time
- Opposition Leader Malema the Target of an Assassination Plot?
- South African DJ, Wife in Coke Bust Worth Millions
- Malema ‘Born Ready’ to Face ‘Bloody Racists’
- Karabo Mokoena ‘Burnt Beyond Recognition’, Court Hears
More From: The Conversation Africa
- Africa: Millions of Urban Africans Still Don’t Have Electricity – Here’s What Can Be Done
- South Africa: Red Tape Is Alienating Academics From Their Own Research and Work
- Africa: Colonialism, Power and Culture – Why Reading French Anthropologist Georges Balandier Is Crucial Today
- Africa: America’s Petty Policy On Used Clothes for Africa
- Africa: African Leaders Are More Constrained By Democratic Rules Than You Think
- Kenya: Kenya Doesn’t Have a Flu Vaccine Policy. Why It Needs One for Babies
- Africa: Weaning African Leaders Off Addiction to Power Is an Ongoing Struggle
- Africa: Why Manufacturing a Key Vaccine in South Africa Is So Important
- Kenya: What Kenya Needs to Do to Stop the University Strike Cycle
- South Africa: Small-Scale Farmers Should Be At the Centre of Land Reform
- Africa: People With Epilepsy Aren’t Protected in Africa
- Namibia: Marginalised Namibians Are Trying to Reclaim Photography After Colonialism
- Africa: Arab-Islamic Education in Sub-Saharan Africa – Going Beyond Clichés to Build the Future
- Kenya: Key Challenges for Kenya in Big Push to Reduce Post-Harvest Losses
- South Africa: Abalone Poaching – Lifting the Lid On Why, How and Who
- South Africa: A More Flexible Curriculum Approach Can Support Student Success
- South Africa: Winnie Madikizela-Mandela’s Legacy – Echoes of Argentina’s Evita
- Southern Africa: Why Shared Toilets in Informal Settlements May Pose a Serious Health Risk
- South Africa: Obstacles Facing a Young Black Farmer in South Africa – a Personal Story
- Africa: How the Law Can Help Change Racist Minds in South Africa
- Congo-Kinshasa: The Country is Still in Crisis but There Is a Way Out
- Kenya: What Universities Can Do to Expand Social Entrepreneurship
- Kenya: Why Kenya Needs Policies to Tackle Dengue and Chikungunya Viruses
- South Africa: Can Jazz Be ‘Woke’ or Is It ‘Just Compressed Air Through a Metal Tube’?
- South Africa: Business Must Tackle Its Deeply Rooted Prejudice
- Africa: What China’s President Xi’s Extended Tenure Means for Africa
- South Africa: Is South Africa’s Opposition Party Ready to Challenge for Power in 2019 Elections?
- Kenya: Why New Wildlife Task Force Is a Step in the Right Direction
- South Africa: An Appreciation of South Africa’s Jazz Stalwart Jonas Gwangwa
- Africa: Ancient DNA Changes Everything We Know About Evolution of Elephants
- Madagascar: Measuring the Economic Impact of Cyclones in Madagascar
- South Africa: Steinhoff’s Board Behaved Badly. Why It Needs to Be Held to Account
- Nigeria: Four Years After, Chibok Girls’ Parents Grieve(Premium Times)
- Nigeria: Buhari’s Criticism Not Targeted At All Nigerian Youth – Presidency(Premium Times)
- South Sudan: Armed Groups Release Over 500 Children(East African)
- Malawi: Youths Warned Against Illegal Collection of Money From People(Malawi News Agency)
- Kenya: Getting Internship in Kenya Is ‘Mission Impossible’(Nation)
- Malawi: Malawi to Receive UK Aid in Tackling Modern Slavery(Nyasa Times)
- Kenya: Family Claims Huruma Hospital Swapped Their Newborn With Dead Child(Nairobi News)
- Kenya: Police Hunt for Al-Shabaab Agents Smuggling Radicalised Youth to Somalia(Capital FM)
- Nigeria: Buhari Said a Lot of Nigerian Youths, Not All Are Lazy – Presidency(Daily Trust)
- Nigeria: Buhari Didn’t Deride Nigerian Youths – Presidency(This Day)
- South Africa: Four Hermanus Public Violence Accused Set Free, Seven Others Wait Sent Back to Jail for the Night(News24Wire)
- Namibia: Judge President Takes Over Land Cases(New Era)
- Uganda: Government Loses Wetlands, Money to Speculative Encroachers(Monitor)
- Tanzania: Land Problems Are Addressed, Mwinyi States(Daily News)
- Kenya: Govt Suspends Mwea Resettlement in Kirinyaga and Embu Counties(Capital FM)
- Tanzania: Residents Call for Reduced Costs of Land Surveying(Citizen)
- South Africa: Hermanus ‘Backyarders’ Pave Their Way for Land Ownership(News24Wire)
- South Africa: Land Reform Has Regressed Under ANC, Academics Say(News24Wire)
- South Africa: Winning Communities(Fahamu)
- South Africa: Land, Factions and Capital in South Africa(Fahamu)
- Zimbabwe: Let’s Rebuild Our Nation As One People(The Herald)
- Nigeria: How to Make Business Easier Among Commonwealth Countries – Buhari(Premium Times)
- Namibia: Mbambo Invites Business Community to Zimbabwe(Namibian)
- Zimbabwe: Sanctions Won’t Distract Us – Mnangagwa(The Herald)
- Kenya: Kenyatta Markets Kenya as Preferred Investor Destination(Nation)
- Nigeria: EIB, AfDB to Finance Development Bank of Nigeria With $70 Million(Premium Times)
- Nigeria: Vast Gas Deposits Can Make Delta Nigeria’s Investment Hub – Okowa(This Day)
- Nigeria: Shell to Invest U.S.$15 Billion in Nigeria, Buhari Says(Daily Trust)
- Malawi: Mutharika Lures London Investors(Nyasa Times)
- Malawi: Mutharika Joins Leaders in Describing Security As Vital for Investment(Malawi News Agency)
- Uganda: Govt Signs U.S.$4 Billion Hoima Oil Refinery Agreement(Observer)
- Sudan: Minister of Oil Receives Invitation for Participation in Canada Oil Exhibition(SNA)
- Nigeria: Oil Price May Hit $75 As Industry Moves to Save $20 Billion On Drilling(Guardian)
- Nigeria: IMF Reverses Oil Prices Downward(Guardian)
- Nigeria: Crude Oil Price Rises to $74, Highest in Four Years(This Day)
- Africa: South African Fuel Payment Mobile App to Be Rolled Out to the Rest of Africa(CIO)
- Nigeria: Fishing in Oily Waters – Bodo’s Long, Painful Wait for Pollution Clean-Up(Guardian)
- Nigeria: Shell to Invest U.S.$15 Billion in Nigeria, Buhari Says(Daily Trust)
- Zimbabwe: Fuel Price Cut Likely(The Herald)
- Sudan: Protests, Concern Over Endless Fuel Crisis, Price Hikes in Sudan(Radio Dabanga)
- Nigeria: Sex-for-Marks Scandal – Why We Suspended Prof Indefinitely – – OAU(Vanguard)
- Rwanda: ‘Smart Classrooms’ a Top Priority – Government(New Times)
- South Africa: Red Tape Is Alienating Academics From Their Own Research and Work(The Conversation Africa)
- Namibia: Education Minister in High Court Dock(Namibian)
- Namibia: Schools Closed in Zambezi Due to Floods(New Era)
- Kenya: Laila Abubakar Named New TUM Vice Chancellor After Topping Interviews(Nation)
- Botswana: Basic Education Ministry Assists Talented Learners Reach Goals(Botswana Daily News)
- Kenya: Recent Research Ranks UON, Moi University Top in Kenya(Capital FM)
- Uganda: Nursing Students Strike Over Poor Meals, Registration Fees(Monitor)
- Nigeria: Apwen to Hold Girl Child Educational Programme(Guardian)
- Nigeria: #WhatWomenWant Campaign Demands Quality Healthcare(Leadership)
- Malawi: Government Sets 2030 As Deadline to End Maternal Deaths(Malawi News Agency)
- Namibia: Chief Rallies for Gender Equality(New Era)
- Uganda: Call to Action – Stop Violence Against Women in Uganda(Monitor)
- Nigeria: Women Entrepreneurs Finance Initiative Allocates Funding to Nigeria, Others(This Day)
- Malawi: Over 50 000 Women to Be Empowered to Cope With Adverse Effects of Climate Change(Malawi News Agency)
- Malawi: Genet Supplies Materials for Sewing Sanitary Pads in Mchinji(Malawi News Agency)
- Eritrea: Effort to Strengthen Organizational Capacity of Women(Shabait)
- Mauritius: Gender Caucus – National Assembly Speaker Elaborates On Findings and Recommendations of Two Reports(Government of Mauritius)
- Kenya: Women’s Group Born of Desperation to Defy a Risky Practice(Nation)
AllAfrica is a voice of, by and about Africa – aggregating, producing and distributing 800 news and information items daily from over 140 African news organizations and our own reporters to an African and global public. We operate from Cape Town, Dakar, Abuja, Monrovia, Nairobi and Washington DC.
- Red tape stops Belfast resident's family, all UK citizens, moving to city
- South Africa ‘frontier vibe’ still drives advances
- Lost City DISCOVERED Next to Johannesburg in South Africa (VIDEO)
- Marsden Grotto owner bemoans ‘red tape’ nightmare which is putting him off investing in South Tyneside
- Thousands protest against job losses in South Africa
- South Africa’s Cape Winelands will be hard to beat in 2019 – Alistair Gibson
- Focus on Africa: Pollsters set the stage for crucial Nigerian elections
- S.Africa to deliver budget faced with debt mountain and blackouts
- Ebola's lost blood: row over samples flown out of Africa as 'big pharma' set to cash in
- How we fell in love while fundraising for cancer research... and ended up battling the illness ourselves
- Should the West stop giving aid to Africa?
- Scientist says ‘very good chance’ of finding alien life on Mars as Nasa’s InSight lander scours Red Planet
South Africa: Red Tape Is Alienating Academics From Their Own Research and Work have 3249 words, post on allafrica.com at April 20, 2018. This is cached page on VietNam Breaking News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.